Some have received offers. We've heard that plans for a returning cast can't be finalized until Sheridan's writing is complete.

The Yellowstone spin-off was not originally designed to include characters from the original series. Although the Puck was reported in February 2024.

Three Yellowstone cast members Kelly Reilly, Cole Hauser and Luke Grimes may join the spin-off. Reilly and Grimes play Beth and Casey Dutton.

Houser plays Rip Wheeler, Beth's husband. All three are looking for significant pay raises to return for the spin-off.

Reilly and Houser are asking rates of $1.2 million and $1.25 million per episode, respectively. Grimes' salary demands were not included.

With the way Yellowstone Season 5A ended, it's hard to see Riley and Wes Bentley returning for a spin-off series.

Their respective characters, Beth and Jamie Dutton, have openly considered killing each other over their ongoing feud.

They have very different goals in mind. Jamie has already gone against the family by calling for his father to be removed as governor of Montana.